The Pie Lady on 5 – South Whitley, IN: Hours, Menu & Directions

Opening hours

Eastern Time

Opening hours have not been published for this bakery yet. Call (260) 224-7992 to check today's hours. Know the hours? Send them to us.

Tap for directions

4391 S State Road 5, South Whitley, IN 46787

Google Maps Apple Maps Waze Bing Maps

Address4391 S State Road 5, South Whitley, IN 46787

Phone(260) 224-7992

StylePie shop

CountyWhitley County

Time zoneEastern Time

About The Pie Lady on 5

The Pie Lady on 5 is a pie shop at 4391 S State Road 5, right in the middle of South Whitley.

Opening hours for The Pie Lady on 5 are not verified in our data. A quick call to (260) 224-7992 before you go saves a wasted trip, especially on holidays.

What to order

Typical items at a pie shop like this one — the bakery's own selection may differ.

Full menu

Fruit pies

Blackberry cobbler pieWild-style blackberries under a tender biscuit-like topping, rustic and juicy with a slight seedy crunch.
Classic apple pieDouble-crust pie with tart and sweet apples, cinnamon and nutmeg under a flaky, sugar-sprinkled top crust.
Cherry lattice pieTart red cherries thickened into a glossy filling beneath a woven lattice crust that bakes up crisp and golden.
Blueberry pieJuicy blueberries with lemon zest and a hint of cinnamon, bubbling up through vents in the flaky top crust.

Cream & custard pies

Southern & heritage pies

Classic pecan pieToasted pecan halves set in a gooey brown sugar and corn syrup filling inside a buttery crust.
Chocolate bourbon pecanPecan pie enriched with dark chocolate chunks and a splash of bourbon for depth and warmth.
Sweet potato pieSmooth, spiced custard of roasted sweet potato, brown sugar and nutmeg; lighter and earthier than pumpkin.
Buttermilk chess pieSimple Southern custard of eggs, sugar, butter and buttermilk, baked until the top caramelizes into a thin crust.

Photos

All photos

The Pie Lady on 5 in South Whitley, IN — The Pie Lady on 5

Slice of apple pie 2 — illustrative photo — Illustrative photo

Small slice of molasses shoofly pie 2022 — illustrative photo — Illustrative photo

Visitor reviews

Write a review

No reviews yet. Been to The Pie Lady on 5? Your review helps other people decide — be the first to write one.

Questions about The Pie Lady on 5

What are The Pie Lady on 5's hours?

We have not verified a weekly schedule for The Pie Lady on 5 yet. Call (260) 224-7992 to confirm before visiting.

Where is The Pie Lady on 5 located?

The Pie Lady on 5 is at 4391 S State Road 5, South Whitley, IN 46787. Tap the map on this page to open turn-by-turn directions.

What is the phone number for The Pie Lady on 5?

The listed phone number is (260) 224-7992.

What should I order at The Pie Lady on 5?

As a pie shop, typical picks include Blackberry cobbler pie, Classic apple pie, Chocolate cream pie, and Butterscotch cream pie. See the full menu page for more.

What other bakeries are near The Pie Lady on 5?

Nearby options include Sugar Creek Donuts (8.2 mi), Blue Moon Bakery (8.3 mi), and Nordmann's Nook (11 mi).